One Finite Planet

One Finite Planet

Foreign fighters: Is it really a surprise that ISIS/ISIL can recruit from the west?

Date Published:

I have heard repeated media statements on how ISIS/ISIL managed to recruit young Sunni Muslims from around the world to join their cause.  It has been stated that society must reach out to the Muslim community to stop these young men being recruited from their midst.

Certainly these recruits from around the world join the battle identifying as Sunni Muslims, but we need to be cautious about the background they are actually recruited from. Surely it is not a deep spiritual belief that drives the people to join such a violent cause, but rather a feeling of repression, angst, frustration and despair.

It may be easier to persuade someone already identifying as Muslim to join such a battle but feelings of repression, angst, frustration and despair are in no way limited to the Muslim community.  Recruiters for ISIL who identify targets can portrait an opportunity to strike back at society, combined with the ultimate perverse ‘boys own’ adventure.  For the rebel without a cause they have a cause to offer.

Consider that in the USA alone around 40,000 people commit suicide per year (source). About 80% of these people are male and while some are in the wrong age group of physical condition, there are more suicidal people than there are that actually commit suicide.

Also consider the disaffection that is felt after events such as took place in Ferguson Missouri. It does not matter who is wrong or right, all it takes as unrest and you have a number of potential recruits ready to strike out against what can be portrayed as repression in any way they can.  An opportunity to behead ‘oppressors’ is going to appeal to a small incensed minority who are also somewhat suicidal no matter what the cause they are fighting for.

Certainly they may go off to battle identifying as Sunni Muslims, but I suggest some may have been recruited solely on the basis of being converted to the cause of striking out against someone rather than to become Muslim simply to study religion.

The caution here is that any disenfranchised group is a target with potential members who may be recruited to a violent suicidal cause. No prerequisite of a life long devotion to Islam is required and there is wider problem created by such a group as ISIL.

The images on the news of ‘foreign fighters’ suggest people that may have moved into Islam and terrorism in one direct step and avoided any radar focused only on those already identified as Muslim.

Any country that has a sufficient number of potentially suicidal people combined with an element of disaffected youth provides an ideal recruiting ground for terrorist groups.  And we all have too many people in both suicidal and disaffected categories.

Table of Contents


Flawed Australian voice of Indigenous People referendum: The irony of a voice campaign that failed to listen.

A tragic lost opportunity. Why didn’t those proposing the voice make changes to remove ambiguity and eliminated enough of the negative perception to win over enough support instead of simply declaring” “No, if that is how you see it you are either racist or stupid!” Was it just that there was no willingness to listen?

Australians had an opportunity in a constitutional referendum to righteously shout loudly “I am not a racist” by voting for a proposition that, at its core, could be seen as fundamentally flawed, divisive and even potentially racist, in the hope even a risk of moving in the direction of apartheid is still better than nothing.

The referendum resulted in a huge setback for action on indigenous disadvantage and while it did seem unlikely to do anything to unify Australians and offer more than some possible affirmative action, the division resulted with even sometimes “yes” voters being encouraged to also be racist.

This is a deeper look trying to see each side from the perspective of the other, with the reality that both sides had a point, and a vast majority of people do want equality and unity.

Perhaps it little more work could bring things together and offer a fresh enough perspective to move beyond just another well-intentioned patronising racism failure like the stolen generations?

Read More »

Crime: A litmus test for inequality?

Around the world, many countries have both a battle with equality for some racial groups and minorities and also a battle with crime-rates within and by those same groups.

Should we consider crime rates the real sentinels of problems and a solution require focusing on factors behind crime rates? Or is the correct response to rising crime rates or crime rates within specific groups an adoption of being “tough on crime”, thus increasing rates of incarceration and even deaths in custody for oppressed minorities and racial groups?

This is an exploration of not adjusting the level of penalties and instead focusing on the core issues and inequalities behind crime-rates. It is clear that it is “damaged people” in general rather than specific racial groups that correlate with elevated crime rates, so why not use crime rates to identify who is facing inequality?

Read More »