One Finite Planet

the mobile pressure is on apple and samsung, and the importance of Tizen

The mobile space is dominated by two brands: Apple and Samsung.

Each has reached such a large market that continuing to increase market share basically requires the other company to falter.

Both have ‘hit the wall’ in terms of market share in the mobile space, with further grown thin market share a real challenge.

For Apple the challenge is growth.  In the last few years, Apple stock has more than doubled in value rougly every 3 years. Even if Samsung stop selling phones the Samsung market share was taken over entirely by Apple, this would on allow for one more doubling.  Instead, Apple needs to find new markets.  If Apple finds a new market every three years to fuel growth, then that new market has to be twice as large as the previous new market. The alternative to new markets or growing market share is to stop growing and that brings its own pain. I will soon do another post specifically on the growth challenges for Apple, but surfice for now that reaching a market share that is difficult to significantly increase is a problem for Apple.

So now to Samsung!

Samsung is a very different company and despite sharing the dominance in mobile devices, Samsung is in a very different position.

As a company, Samsung is far more diverse than Apple, and mobile devices are a far smaller percentage of revenue.  Despite this greater diversity, and Samsung actually selling more devices than Apple, the market cap of Samsung is far smaller than that of Apple and there is not the same historic rate of growth to maintain.

As a mobile device company, the big difference is that unlike Apple, Samsung does not have its own ‘ecosystem’ to generate additional profits from those mobile devices.  Instead, Samsung faces competion from other device manufactures competing within the same ecosystem.  Within the Android market, Samsung holds a level of market share impossible to significantly increase, and extremely difficult to maintain. Within Android there is no great barrier to consumers switching brands and running an idenitcal platform reduces the ability for product differentiation placing Samsung at the risk of simply losing market share as fashions change.

The answer for Samsung is Tizen.

Tizen can provide Samsung with an ecosystem that Samsung can control and earn ecosystem profits instead of letting google earn profits on all those Samsung devices. Bringing ecosystems to citical mass is extremely challenging and changing ecosystems risks alientating consumers.  Samsnug has sucessfully moved its ‘wearable’ devices from an intitial launch on Android across to Tizen but has only had false starts on phones so far.

But owning an ecosystem is realistically Samsungs only way to keep mobile device revenues where they are.  A wearables ecosystem could be sufficient if over time wearables become more significant than phones, but I doubt it.  Expect Samsung to keep moving with Tizen, or lose mobile device revenues.


Table of Contents


Carbon Capture and Storage: When it works, and why it doesn’t for work ‘blue hydrogen’.

There are both vocal supporters and vocal opponents of carbon capture and storage, and there are arguments for both sides. This page goes beyond reporting on how carbon capture and storage fails to make current ‘blue hydrogen’ projects sustainable, and looks at the underlying principle that dictates why carbon capture and storage, despite having genuine valuable applications, can never enable ‘blue hydrogen’ to be environmentally sustainable, but is so popular politically.

Read More »

Hydrogen: Facts vs Myths, blue vs green.

There is much talk of a ‘hydrogen economy’, but what is the substance behind it all? There are many myths but hydrogen can be :

  • ‘green’ hydrogen, not a source of energy, but a less efficient storage stepping stone on the path to battery power.
    • or
  • blue/grey hydrogen, the fossil fuel industries’ hope for greenwashing emissions.

This exploration provides looks at the reality, and the myths about hydrogen, and provides background for other pages such as: Electric or Hydrogen Cars and Hydrogen Scams.

Read More »